9 Thrift Store Finds I Always Buy for Vintage Styling

There’s something special about the thrill of the thrift — that moment when you stumble across a one-of-a-kind vintage gem just waiting to be brought home.

Over the years, I’ve developed a list of go-to items I never leave behind when I’m thrifting. These pieces add instant charm, warmth, and personality to any space, and today, I’m sharing nine thrift store finds I always buy for vintage styling in our Vermont and Maine homes.

And as part of this week’s Thrifting with the Gals, you’ll find even more inspiring ideas from my vintage-loving friends at the bottom of this post!

9 Thrift Store Finds I Always Buy for Vintage Styling

1. Vintage Pitchers

Whether it’s transferware, ironstone, or hand-thrown pottery, I never pass up a good vintage pitcher. They’re perfect for flowers, kitchen styling, or even just lining open shelves with character.

2. Wooden Cutting Boards

These add instant warmth and texture to any kitchen or dining space. I love mixing different shapes and wood tones for that well-loved, collected look.

3. Old Baskets

From shallow trays to tall-handled harvest baskets, vintage baskets are endlessly useful. I style them on the porch, by the fireplace, and even hanging on the walls.

4. Brass Candlesticks

They bring a soft glow and vintage elegance to tablescapes, mantels, or hutches. I especially love mixing mismatched pairs for a romantic, old-world feel.

5. Ironstone or White Dishes

Thrifted ironstone is a staple in my vintage kitchen styling. It layers beautifully with other textures and makes everyday items feel special.

Shop Vintage Ironstone

6. Vintage Art or Frames

I always peek through the art section. Whether it’s a pastoral landscape or a beautifully aged frame, vintage artwork brings soul to a space.

7. Old Books

Weathered pages, faded covers, and classic titles — vintage books are perfect for stacking on tables or adding height and charm to vignettes.

8. Crocks and Stoneware

These timeless pieces work beautifully for storing kitchen utensils, holding flowers, or simply grounding a space with vintage weight and texture.

Shop Vintage Crocks

9. Linens and Textiles

I’m always on the lookout for embroidered napkins, old flour sack towels, or hand-stitched table runners. They’re easy to layer into everyday decor or use for seasonal styling.

Want to save this list for your next thrifting trip? Click below to download the checklist!

Thrifting is such a joy — not just for the treasure hunt but for the way these little pieces of the past add story and soul to our homes.

These nine finds are my go-to favorites, and I hope they inspire you to start (or grow!) your own collection of vintage treasures. Whether you’re styling shelves, setting a cozy table, or just adding a bit of charm to a corner, the thrift store holds endless inspiration.

What’s your #1 thrift store find you always look for? Share it in the comments — I’d love to hear!

Pin forLater!